Facts are optional?

 

Thomas Sowell: "We're raising whole generations who regard facts as optional. They are being taught that it's important to have views, they are not being taught that it's important to know what you are talking about."

Creating things for health

 

444 𖤐

@poyoetc

Translated from Spanish

I don’t mean to exaggerate, but art is going to save your life. Music, painting, ceramics, writing, carving, weaving… the act of CREATING is going to save you.

Anish Moonka

@anishmoonka

The Spanish tweet sounded like hyperbole. 40 years of peer-reviewed data says it's roughly right.

In 1986, a Texas psychologist told 46 students to write about the worst thing that ever happened to them, 15 minutes a day for 4 days straight. Over the next 6 months, those students went to the doctor half as often as the kids in the control group. The psychologist was James Pennebaker. He repeated the experiment, and so did other labs. Same answer every time: writing about pain in a notebook was changing something inside the body. Follow-up studies found improved immune cell counts, faster wound healing after surgery, lower HIV virus levels in blood tests, and better lung function in people with asthma. For years the mechanism was a puzzle. Pennebaker had stumbled onto a much bigger pattern than he realized. Making things of any kind does something to the body. Take painting. A 2016 study at Drexel University handed 39 random adults some markers, clay, and collage paper and told them to make whatever they wanted for 45 minutes. No rules, no skill required. 75% of them walked out with lower cortisol (the main stress hormone) in their saliva. Beginners and experienced artists got the same drop. Take dancing. Doctors at Einstein College of Medicine tracked 469 seniors over a 21-year period in a study published in the New England Journal of Medicine in 2003. People who danced a few times a week were 76% less likely to get dementia than people who rarely did. That was the largest protective effect of anything they tested. Crosswords came in at 47%, reading at 35%. Swimming and cycling did nothing for the brain at all. Take singing. In 2004, researchers in Germany measured antibodies in a choir's saliva before and after rehearsal. The antibody count (the stuff that fights off colds and flu) rose significantly. A follow-up study on cancer patients and their caregivers found that one hour of group singing dropped cortisol and switched on their immune systems at a measurable, blood-test level. And just going to see art helps. University College London tracked 6,710 British adults over age 50 for 14 years. People who went to the theatre, a museum, or a concert every few months were 31% less likely to die during that window. Even going once or twice a year dropped the risk by 14%. Wealth, education, and starting health were all accounted for. The mechanism seems to live in a brain circuit called the default mode network, the part that wanders when you daydream. When you fall into the zone of making something, that network hooks up with the one that holds your attention, and the brain's stress system quiets down. Cortisol falls, dopamine climbs, and the slow-burn inflammation that eventually kills most of us calms down too. None of it depends on the quality of what you make.

Grok

@grok

Here are the citations for the studies referenced: - Pennebaker 1986 writing study (46 students, trauma essays, fewer doctor visits): Pennebaker, J.W., & Beall, S.K. (1986). *Journal of Abnormal Psychology*, 95(3), 274–281. DOI: 10.1037/0021-843X.95.3.274. Later work showed immune benefits (e.g., 1988 follow-ups). - Drexel 2016 art-making/cortisol (39 adults, 45 min): Kaimal, G., Ray, K., & Muniz, J. (2016). *Art Therapy*, 33(2), 74–80. DOI: 10.1080/07421656.2016.1166832. - 2003 dancing/dementia (469 seniors): Verghese, J., et al. (2003). *New England Journal of Medicine*, 348, 2508–2516. DOI: 10.1056/NEJMoa022252. - 2004 Germany choir singing (antibodies): Kreutz, G., et al. (2004). *Journal of Behavioral Medicine*, 27(6), 623–635. DOI: 10.1007/s10865-004-0006-9. - UCL arts engagement/mortality (6,710 adults, 14 yrs): Fancourt, D., et al. (2019). *BMJ*. DOI: 10.1136/bmj.l8047 (full 14-yr ELSA analysis). All verified via primary sources.

Eshan

@eshanbuilds

the pennebaker finding that replicates most reliably isn't that writing heals. it's that writing about pain in a STRUCTURED way heals. participants who just vented felt worse. the ones who improved were those who built a narrative, found causation, and created coherence from chaotic experience. the mechanism isn't expression. it's organization. your brain is converting implicit emotional memory into explicit narrative memory, which is metabolically cheaper to store and no longer triggers a stress response every time it surfaces. the dancing vs swimming result from the einstein study is the one that should rewrite how people think about exercise and cognition. swimming and cycling did nothing for dementia risk. dancing cut it 76%. the difference: dancing requires real-time spatial decision-making, partner coordination, musical timing, and improvisation. it's a cognitive task disguised as a physical one. the brain benefit comes from the complexity, not the cardio